Community Hospital

Resource Guide

A Vital Guide for Hospital Senior Leaders to Develop Impactful Organ, Eye and Tissue Donation Practices

A Community Hospital Resource Guide

Community Hospital Resource Guide
Fall 2019 Special Edition
Disclaimers for Community Resource Toolbox, the Community Hospital Resource Guide and Transplant Quality Resources Guide

For linking to the Community Resource Toolbox, the Community Hospital Resource Guide and Transplant Quality Resources Guide and Tools, please use the following disclaimers:

Community Resource Toolbox Disclaimer:

The Community Resource Toolbox includes a variety of resources created, collected, and/or compiled by the Organ Donation and Transplantation Alliance. (Insert name of your organization) is neither affiliated with nor endorsed by the Alliance and claims no ownership in any of the Community Resource Toolbox materials. By clicking this link, you will be directed to the Alliance’s website located at https://www.organdonationalliance.org//resources/toolbox/.

Please use the Alliance logo on your website. Link here to locate and download a version of the logo that best suits your site:

Access Alliance Logo Files

Transplant Resource Guide (TRG) Disclaimer:

The Transplant Resource Guide (TRG) includes a variety of resources created, collected, and/or compiled by the Organ Donation and Transplantation Alliance. (Insert name of your organization) is neither affiliated with nor endorsed by the Alliance and claims no ownership in any of the Transplant Resource Guide (TRG) materials. By clicking this link, you will be directed to the Alliance’s website located at https://www.organdonationalliance.org/resources/transplant-resource-guide/.

Please use the Alliance logo on your website. Link here to locate and download a version of the logo that best suits your site:

Access Alliance Logo Files

Community Hospital Resource Guide Disclaimer:

The Community Hospital Resource Guide includes a variety of resources created, collected, and/or compiled by the Organ Donation and Transplantation Alliance. (Insert name of your organization) is neither affiliated with nor endorsed by the Alliance and claims no ownership in any of the Community Hospital Resource Guide materials. By clicking this link, you will be directed to the Alliance’s website located at https://www.organdonationalliance.org/resources/community-hospital-resource-guide/.

Please use the Alliance logo on your website. Link here to locate and download a version of the logo that best suits your site:

Access Alliance Logo Files

The Alliance Resource Section

Essential 2

Regulatory Compliance and Legal Considerations

This essential outlines the requirements for a hospital’s compliance with donation related laws, regulations and accreditation standards. Click on the model element detail link to navigate to a comprehensive chapter for more in-depth information, details and guidance.

Fact Finding Questions CEOs May Ask of Their Senior Leadership:

  1. Are we in compliance with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) Hospital Conditions of Participation (CoPs) for organ donation and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulations for eye and tissue donation?
  2. Do our policies align with our state’s Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (UAGA), Uniform Determination of Death Act (UDDA), CMS CoPs, Trauma Certification (if applicable), and hospital accreditation standards (e.g. TJC, DNV, AOA, etc.)?

Model Elements for Regulatory & Legal Consideration

Detailed Components of Regulatory Compliance & Legal Considerations

  1. Be familiar with the CMS CoPs, which issues a federal regulatory outline of hospital requirements in relation to organ, eye, and tissue donation.
  2. Be familiar with the hospital standards provided by your accrediting organization(s) as it relates to organ, eye and tissue donation.
  3. Be familiar with the law in your state regarding the ability for individuals to designate themselves as organ, eye and tissue donors on donor registries and the legal implications of their decision.
  4. Be aware of the provisions for organ procurement and transplantation in the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA).
  5. Ensure compliance with your state’s Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (UAGA).
  6. Ensure compliance with your state’s Uniform Determination of Death Act (UDDA).
  7. Ensure compliance with the UAGA Hierarchy of Authorization. When no other legal authorizing party is reasonably available, UAGA allows hospital administration to authorize donation.
  8. Ensure compliance to honor first person authorization (registered donor’s wishes) and address the hospital’s response in situations when family objects to the patient’s donor designation.
  9. Consider having a representative from your legal/ethics department available for potentially sensitive cases.
  1. The Alliance Organ Donation Toolbox: National Legislation Related to Organ, Eye, and Tissue Donation
  2. The Alliance Organ Donation Toolbox: State Legislation References Related to the Uniform Determination of Death Act
  3. First Person Authorization (FPA) Status by State
  4. Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (POLST vs. Advance Directive)
  5. The Alliance Hospital C-Suite Snapshots Series 6. Terminology Glossary

1. CMS Conditions of participation for hospitals: organ, tissue and eye procurement. Title 42. Chapter IV. Subchapter G. §482.45. Washington, D.C.: U.S. G.P.O.

2. Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations. Health Care at the Crossroads: Strategies for Narrowing the Organ Donation Gap and Protecting Patients. https://www.jointcommission.org.

LEGISLATIVE RESOURCES

This section is intended to provide a brief and pertinent overview into the regulatory environment of organ donation and procurement, to help and serve organ and tissue donation and procurement within community hospitals.

CENTERS FOR MEDICARE AND MEDICAID SERVICES (CMS) CONDITIONS OF PARTICIPATION
33856 Federal Register / Vol. 63, No. 119 / Rules and Regulations

These federal regulations apply to hospitals participating in the Medicare Program, where the aim is to establish and guide collaboration their local OPOs, tissue and eye banks, and structure to optimize donation outcomes to meet the critical need for transplantation within our community. The highlights of the regulation (§482.45) are:

    1. The hospital must have written policies and procedures to address its organ procurement responsibilities.
    2. As such the hospital must have a written agreement with an OPO and must have a written agreement with at least one tissue and eye bank.
    3. At a minimum, the written agreement must address the following:
      1. Criteria for obligatory referral, including the timely notification to the OPO of all individuals whose death is imminent or who have died in the hospital;
      2. Definitions of “imminent death” and “timely notification”;
      3. The specific responsibility of the OPO to determine medical suitability for organ and tissue/eye donation
      4. Interventions that the hospital will undertake to maintain potential organ donors so that the organs remain viable
      5. OPO notification when the patient or surrogate instructs a Do Not Resuscitate (DNR),before the OPO has had the opportunity to determine medical suitability or discuss the option of donation with the patient or surrogates.
    4. The hospital must collaborate with the OPO to ensure that each family of a potential donor is presented the opportunity for donation. The individual chosen to make the request to the family must be from the OPO, or a ‘designated requestor’ within the hospital (an individual having completed an OPO instructed/approved course in requesting organ/tissue donation). Authorization for donation is more likely when
      1. family members are given time to understand and accept their relative’s death before the donation request is made.
      2. the request is made by the OPO in conjunction with an introduction by hospital staff.
      3. the setting in which the request is made should be quiet and private
    5. The hospital should cooperate with the OPO, eye and tissue bank in
      1. providing staff education on donation;
      2. reviewing death records to improve identification of potential donors;
      3. maintaining potential donors while necessary testing and placement of potential donated organs, tissues and eyes takes place.

UNIFORM ANATOMICAL GIFT ACT (UAGA)
https://www.uniformlaws.org/viewdocument/final-act-with-comments-1?CommunityKey=015e18ad-4806-4dffb011-8e1ebc0d1d0f&tab=librarydocuments

The Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (UAGA) is model legislation adopted in all states and the District of Columbia and addresses authorization for deceased donation, hospital obligations, and OPO responsibilities. Although there is some variation among state laws, the general principles are consistent across states. The following is a high level overview of the provisions of the UAGA:

  • The UAGA allows an individual to make a legally binding anatomical gift prior to death. An individual may register their decision through a donor registry (e.g., DMV registry or Donate Life America) or through an alternative document of gift such as an organ donor card/form or advance directive.
  • An individual may decide not to donate his or her organs by signing a refusal or revocation of donation, or by communicating their intent during a terminal illness to 2 individuals, one of whom is a disinterested witness (except if donation was authorized in a will).
  • If an individual has designated his or herself as a donor, no other individual may override a competent adult’s prior decision to donate.
  • If an individual has not made a decision, a surrogate decision maker may authorize donation. The UAGA lists the individuals who may authorize donation in the following order of priority:
    1. Duly authorized healthcare agents with power of attorney;
    2. Parents or guardian of unemancipated minors;
    3. Adult children;
    4. Parents of the adult patient;
    5. Adult siblings;
    6. Adult grandchildren;
    7. Grandparents;
    8. An adult who exhibited special care and concern for the decedent;
    9. Guardians of adult patients at the time of death; and
    10. Any other person having the authority under law to dispose of the patient’s body. This includes coroners and medical examiners.
  • The hierarchy of authorizing parties may differ by state. It is recommended that the hospital familiarize themselves with their state’s UAGA.
  • If more than one member of a class is reasonably available, the donation is made only if a majority of members support the donation.
  • Minors, if eligible under other law to apply for a driver license, or if meeting minimum age to register on their state donor registry, are empowered to be a registered donor. A parent or legal guardian can override their decision.
  • When a hospital refers an individual at or near death to an OPO, the OPO may conduct any reasonable examination necessary to ensure the medical suitability for transplantation. During that time, the hospital must maintain the patient to support the possibility of donation, unless the hospital or OPO knows or discovers that the individual expressed a contrary intent.
  • If an advance directive seems to conflict with organ donation, the hospital must expeditiously confer with the patient or surrogates, as well as the OPO, to resolve the conflict. During that time, the patient should be maintained to support the possibility of donation.
  • Priority is given to the use of organs for transplantation or therapy over education or research, unless a donor expresses a different intent.

*1986—Public Law 99-509, The Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1986, October 21, 1986—Section 1138 of the Social Security Act – Included new requirements pertaining to organ procurement and transplantation and participation in the Medicare and Medicaid programs.

*1985—Public Law 99-272, The Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 1985, April 7, 1986—Required that states have written standards regarding coverage of organ transplants in order to qualify for federal payments under Title XIX of the Social Security Act.

HEALTH INSURANCE PORTABILITY AND ACCOUNTABILITY ACT (HIPAA)
(Organ Procurement Transplantation Provisions)
https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/laws-regulations/index.html

As Covered Entities, hospitals are subject to HIPAA regulations which address the use and disclosure of protected health information with the patient’s authorization or when the disclosure fits within a regulatory exception to the authorization requirement. There are two regulatory exemptions that permit hospitals to disclose information to the OPO without authorization:

      • First, a healthcare provider may use or disclose information if and as required by law. This exemption allows OPOs and hospitals to comply with the Medicare Conditions of Participation, 42 C.F.R § 482.45 which specifically require referrals of imminent deaths to an OPO and require hospitals to allow OPOs to conduct audits of death records.
      • Secondly, section §164.512(h) allows information to be released to OPOs or other entities involved in the procurement, banking or transplantation of cadaveric organs, eyes, or tissue for the purposes of facilitating organ, eye or tissue donation and transplantation. This permits the release of information by and to, hospitals, transplant hospitals, UNOS, tissue banks and laboratories, letting OPOs do their core jobs; the coordination of donation and transplant, and the review of records.

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has determined that OPOs are not ‘business associates’ of hospitals, nor are OPOs “healthcare providers” when they are performing OPO functions.

STATE ORGAN DONOR REGISTRIES

State donor registries are managed in accordance with respective state laws. The responsible government agency varies by state. Some registries are contractually operated by state/regional Donate Life organizations. Most registries integrate with their state’s driver license issuing agency to capture donor registrations from driver license transactions. Most registries also allow individuals to register or modify their donation decision online via the state registry website. For information on your state’s donor registry, visit https://www.organdonor.gov/register.html.

NATIONAL DONATE LIFE REGISTRY

Donate Life America is a 501(c)3 nonprofit organization that among its many public awareness campaigns and initiatives, manages the National Donate Life Registry at https://www.RegisterMe.org. Having a national registry allows Donate Life America to work with national partners like Apple and Walgreens to bring the donor registration opportunity to smart phones, pharmacy apps, etc. For more information about the national registry, including FAQs, visit https://www.donatelife.net/national-donate-life-registry/.

If you are interested in a customizable national campaign page at RegisterMe.org for your hospital, please contact Hilary Czarda at Donate Life America (h[email protected]), or let your OPO team know you are interested in a campaign page at RegisterMe.org.

THE JOINT COMMISSION
https://www.jointcommission.org/accreditation/hospitals.aspx

The Joint Commission maintains standards for organ and tissue donation consistent with the CMS regulations (e.g. requirement that hospitals must have a written agreement with an affiliated OPO). Standards LD.3.110 and TS.01.01.01 require that hospitals develop and implement written policies and procedures for the donation and procurement of organs and tissues.

Details of these and other requirements include:

      • Criteria for identifying potential organ and tissue donors, and directly notifying the OPO or tissue bank of those potential donors (while maintaining records of notification).
      • Mechanisms for notifying the family of potential organ and tissue donors of the possibility to donate or to decline to donate any organs or tissues, as well as a method of recording the decision, for subsequent review. This should be performed by an OPO trained/approved designated requestor.
      • Fulfillment of patient’s wishes on end of life care, including organ donation, within the limits of the law or hospital resources (Standard RI.2.80).
      • Staff education in the use of discretion and sensitivity towards the circumstances, wishes, and beliefs of the families of potential donors.
      • Recognition that the OPO determines medical suitability of organs for donation, while the OPO or tissue/eye bank determine medical suitability for donation of tissues or eyes.

The Joint Commission has clarified that OPOs are not considered contracted services (like HIPAA exemptions above), and details which federal regulations apply to OPOs.

The Healthcare Facilities Accreditation Program (HFAP) and the DNV GL National Integrated Accreditation for Healthcare Organizations (NIAHO) are two other organizations with requirements consistent with the Joint Commission standards and CMS regulations. DNV Organ and Tissue Standards

FIRST PERSON AUTHORIZATION

The 2006 Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (UAGA) is limited in scope to deceased donors, and as identified above, simplifies the document of gift.

It also, however, strengthens the power of an individual to make lasting decisions on the disposition of their body parts after death that cannot be overridden by others after death. This applies to decisions both authorizing or refusing donation. The OPO has legal authority to proceed with organ procurement even over the objection of the registered donor’s family. The hospital has a legal responsibility to support the donor’s instructions and cooperate with the OPO to move forward with donation.

Act/Regulation Date Passed / Updated Relevant Sections Topics of Reference
Medicare Conditions of Participation 1998 42 CFR Part 48 Routine Death Notification Legislation
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act 1986 99-272; 99-509 Hospitals must have policies in place to offer all families of deceased patients the opportunity to donate their loved one’s organs
Uniform Anatomical Gift Act 2006 & 2007 N/A Authorization for Deceased Organ Donation; Hospital and OPO Responsibilities
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act 1996 164.12(h); 164.512 Governs use and disclosure of protected health information by Covered Entity and permits disclosure to OPOs without authorization
The Joint Commission 2007 LD.3.110 Requires policies within hospitals for organ and tissue procurement and donation
The Joint Commission 2007 7 RI.2.80 Addresses end of life wishes, including documentation and fulfillment of the patient’s wishes regarding organ donation
The Joint Commission 2007 HR.2.10; HR.2.30 Obligates hospitals to provide orientation and ongoing training in issues, regulations, laws and the needs of the patient population
The Joint Commission 2009 9 TS.01.01.01 Details elements of performance in the development and implementation of written policies and procedures for donating and procuring organs and tissues
Healthcare Facilities Accreditation Program 2015 14.00.01-11 Governs hospital responsibilities regarding organ donation
Healthcare Facilities Accreditation Program 2015 15.01.09 Describes patient and their surrogate’s rights regarding organ donation
State Act / Statute / Code Sections Topic
AL Alabama Code (Determination of Death) 22-31-1 Determination of Death
AK Alaska Code (Determination of Death) 09.68.120 Determination of Death
AK Alaska Code (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 13.52.173 Authorization for decision making in organ donation
AR Arkansas Code (Uniform Determination of Death) 20-17-101 Determination of Death
AR Arkansas Code (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 20-17-6 Authorization for decision making in organ donation
AZ Arizona Revised Statute 14-1107 Determination of Death
AZ Arizona Revised Statute (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 36-841-864 Authorization for decision making in organ donation
CA Health and Safety Code 1254.4 Hospitals must offer “reasonably brief” accommodation for families between declaration of brain death and discontinuation of cardiopulmonary support
CA Health and Safety Code (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 7150 Authorization for decision making in organ donation
CA Health and Safety Code 7184 Required Request Act
CA Health and Safety Code (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 7180 Determination of Death
CO Colorado State Law (Determination of Death) 12-36-136 Determination of Death
CT Connecticut General Statutes (Continuation or removal of life support system) 19a-504a. Determination of Death
DC District of Columbia Official Code (Human Health Care and Safety) 2001.7-601 Determination of Death
DE Delaware State Health and Safety Code (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 1760 Determination of Death
FL Florida State Law (Recognition of brain death under certain circumstances) 382.009 Determination of Death
GA Georgia Code. Health. (Criteria for determining death; immunity from liability) 31-10-16 Determination of Death
HI Hawaii Revised Statutes (Evidence of death or status) 560:1-107 Determination of Death
ID Idaho Code (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 39-3401 Authorization for decision making in organ donation
ID Idaho Statute (Professions, Vocations and Businesses – Physicians and Surgeons – Definition and Procedure for Determination of Death) 54-1819 Determination of Death
IL Illinois Compiled Statutes (Health Care Surrogate Act) 755 ILCS 40/10 Determination of Death
IN Indiana State Law (Uniform Determination of Death Act) IC 1-1-4-3 Determination of Death
IA Iowa State Law (Death) 702.8 Determination of Death
KS Kansas State Law (Determination of Death) 77-205 Determination of Death
KY Kentucky State Law (Determination of Death — Minimal conditions to be met) 446.400 Determination of Death
LA Louisiana State Law (Definition of Death) 111 Determination of Death
ME Maine State Law (Title 22: Health and Welfare Subtitle 2: Health Part 6: Births, Marriages and Deaths Chapter 706: Uniform Determination of Death Act) 2811 Determination of Death
MD Maryland State Law (Article – Health – General) 5–202. Determination of Death
MA Massachusetts General Law (Uniform Probate Code – Evidence of Death or Status) 1-107 Determination of Death
MI Michigan State Law (Determination of Death Act, 90 of 1992) 333.1033 Determination of Death
MN Minnesota Statutes (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 145.135 Determination of Death
MS Mississippi Code Title 41. Public Health. 41-36-3 Determination of Death
MO Missouri Revised Statutes (Title XII – Public Health and Welfare – Chapter 194 Death – Disposition of Dead Bodies) 194.005 Determination of Death
MT Montana Code (Determination of Death) 50-22-101 Determination of Death
MT Montana Code (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 72-17-101 Authorization for decision making in organ donation
NE Nebraska Revised Statute 71-7202 Determination of Death
NV Nevada Revised Statutes (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 451.007 Determination of Death
NH New Hampshire (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 141-D:1 Determination of Death
NJ New Jersey Statutes (New Jersey Declaration of Death Act 26:6A-1 et seq Determination of Death
NJ New Jersey Statutes (New Jersey Declaration of Death Act) 12-2-4 Determination of Death
NM New Mexico State Law (Determination of Death) 26:6A-1 et seq Determination of Death
NY New York Codes, Rules and Regulations (Determination of Death) 400.16 Determination of Death
NC North Carolina General Statutes (Death; determination by physician) 90-323 Determination of Death
ND North Dakota Code (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 23-06.3 Determination of Death
OH Ohio Revised Code (Definition of Death) 2108.40 Determination of Death
OK Oklahoma Statutes (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 63-3121 Determination of Death
OR Oregon Revised Statutes (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 432.300 Determination of Death
PA Statutes of Pennsylvania (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 1982, P.L.1401, No.323 Determination of Death
RI Rhode Island General Laws (Uniform Determination of Death) 23-4-16 Determination of Death
SC South Carolina Code of Laws (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 44-43-450 Determination of Death
SD South Dakota Codified Laws (Determination of Death) 34-25-18.1 Determination of Death
TN Tennessee Code (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 68-3-501 Determination of Death
TN Texas Health and Safety Code 671.001 Determination of Death
UT Utah Health Code (Revised Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 26-28 Authorization for decision making in organ donation
UT Utah Health Code (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 26-34-2 Determination of Death
VT Vermont Statutes (Determination of Death) 18 V.S. A §5218 Determination of Death
VA Code of Virginia (Determination of Death) 54.1-2972 Determination of Death
WA Revised Washington Code (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act) 68.64.010 Authorization for decision making in organ donation
WA Washington State Supreme Court (Uniform Determination of Death Act adopted in Washington State) 94 Wn.2d 407, 617 P.2d 731 Determination of Death
WV West Virginia Code (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 16-10-1 Determination of Death
WI Wisconsin Statute (Determination of Death) 146.71 Determination of Death
WY Wyoming Statute (Uniform Determination of Death Act) 35-19-101 Determination of Death
State FPA Online Registry Registry Integrated with DMV Comments
Alabama Y https://alabamalifelegacy.org Y
Alaska Y https://alaskadonorregistry.org Y
Arizona Y https://www.donatelifeaz.org/
Arkansas Y https://alaskadonorregistry.org Y
California Y hhttps://donatelifecalifornia.org/
https://www.donevidacalifornia.org/
Y
Colorado Y https://www.donatelifecolorado.org/ Y Registry accessed through Statline
Connecticut Y http://donatelifenewengland.org/ Y
Delaware Y https://www.donatelife.net Y
District of Columbia Y https://www.donatelifedc.org/ Y
Florida Y https://www.donatelifeflorida.org/ Y
Georgia No https://www.donatelifegeorgia.org/ Y
Hawaii Y http://www.legacyoflifehawaii.org/ Y DMV also registers Advance directives
Idaho Y https://www.yesidaho.org/ Y
Illinois Y https://www.ilsos.gov/organdonorregister/ Y
Indiana Y https://www.donatelifeindiana.org/ Y
Iowa Y https://www.iowadonornetwork.org/ In Progress
Kansas Y https://www.donatelifekansas.com/ Y Registry housed within OPO
Kentucky Y https://donatelifeky.org/ Y
Louisiana Y https://www.donatelifela.org/ Y
Maine Y http://donatelifenewengland.org/ Y
Maryland Y http://www.donatelifemaryland.org/ Y
Massachusetts No https://www.mass.gov/how-to/register-asan-organ-donor-at-the-rmv Y
Michigan Y https://services2.sos.state.mi.us/OrganDonor/Pages/Registry.aspx Y
Minnesota Y https://www.lifesourcedonorregistry.org/ Y
Mississippi Y https://msora.org/register/
Missouri Y https://www.missouriorgandonor.com/ Y
Montana Y https://www.donatelifetoday.com/ Y
Nebraska Y https://liveonnebraska.org/register/ Y
Nevada Y https://www.donoregistry.org/register/nv#/enroll Y
New Hampshire Y http://neds.org/register-now/ Y
New Jersey Y https://www.njsharingnetwork.org/register-today Y
New Mexico Y https://donatelifenm.org/ Y
New York Y https://donatelife.ny.gov/register/ Y – and voter registration New registry with FPA authority for those registered after 07/23/2008
North Carolina Y https://www.donatelifenc.org/register/new Y
North Dakota Y https://apps.nd.gov/dot/dlts/dlos/donorChange.htm Y
Ohio Y http://donatelifeohio.org/register Y
Oklahoma Y https://www.lifeshareregistry.org/register/ Y
Oregon Y https://www.donatelifenw.org/ Y
Pennsylvania Y https://www.donatelifepa.org/ Y
Rhode Island Y http://donatelifenewengland.org/ Y
South Carolina Y https://apps.sd.gov/ps09onlinerenewal/or gandonorupdate.aspx Y
Tennessee Y https://donatelifetn.org/Donor/Create Y
Texas Y https://www.donatelifetexas.org/ Y
Utah Y https://www.yesutah.org/ Y
Vermont No http://donatelifevt.org/ Y
Virginia Y https://www.donatelifevirginia.org/ Y
Washington Y https://www.donatelifetoday.com/ Y
West Virginia Y https://donatelife.wv.gov/ Y
Wisconsin Y https://health.wisconsin.gov/donorRegistry/public/donate.html Y
Wyoming Y https://www.donatelifewyoming.org/ Y

The Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (POLST) Paradigm Form is a medical order that instructs emergency healthcare professionals what to do in case of a medical crisis, in circumstances where the patient cannot speak for him or herself.

An Advance Directive is a legal document that supplies a surrogate medical decision maker in circumstances where the patient tells cannot speak for him/herself and gives general direction on treatments the patient does or does not want, in order to help create a treatment plan.

POLST Paradigm Form Advance Directive Do Not Resuscitate End of Life Care
Type of document Medical order Legal document Medical order Medical order
Who completes? Healthcare professional Individual Healthcare professional Healthcare professional
Who needs one? Individuals with critical advanced illnesses or injury, whose current health status indicates the need for standing medical orders for emergent or future medical care. A physician with detailed knowledge of the patient’s medical history who believes the patient would die within one year. All competent adults Any critically ill or injured individual who has made a prior determination that they do not want to be resuscitated in case of cardiopulmonary arrest A critically ill or injured individual who has decided they do not want to continue receiving currentcare supporting their life
What is communicated? Specific medical orders for treatment wishes during a medical emergency, derived from shared decision making between the patient and their healthcare professional. General wishes about treatment wishes. May help guide treatment plan after a medical emergency. Specific medical order on treatment during a cardiopulmonary arrest in hospital, derived from shared decision making between the patient (or surrogate) and their healthcare professional. Specific medical order on treatment during the end of a patient’s life, guiding what may be discontinued, and what analgesia and sedation may be used to limit distress or pain.
Can EMS use? Yes No No No
Ease in locating Very easy to find. Ease in locating Very easy to find. Not very easy to find. Depends on where patient keeps it and if they have told someone where it is, given a copy to surrogate or to healthcare professional to put in his/her medical record. Easy to find within a specific hospital system – exists within hospital record. It has no effect within other hospitals, apart from communicating intent. Easy to find within a specific hospital system – exists within hospital record. It has no effect within other hospitals, apart from communicating intent.
Does it need to be signed by the patient? No – but having the form signed by the patient (or durable power of attorney for healthcare, or another authorized surrogate) is encouraged. Yes – the document has no relevance otherwise. No No
Required for end-of-life care to proceed? No No Yes Yes
Does it prevent organ donation? No – these patients may have serious illness limiting (but not removing) options for donation. Not unless specifically stated – while these directives often contain instructions on limiting care in terminal illness, there is usually no prohibition on extending care briefly to facilitate donation (especially when patient has given FPA). In such circumstances, the UAGA asks the healthcare team to hasten discussions between the patient’s family and the OPO. No No
Does it mean ‘Do Not Treat?’ No – a POLST allows the patient and their physician to determine what treatments they want to occur. Reasonable analgesia and general comfort measures (food and fluid by mouth) are always provided. No – the advance directive can express what treatment is wanted and what is not wanted. Reasonable analgesia and comfort are always appropriate, even if curative treatment is not wanted. No – it merely limits intervention during cardiopulmonary arrest. No – it limits active therapies prolonging life, focusing instead on analgesia and sedation, which should continue to be provided.