The Alliance Executive

Insight Series

The executive insight series is designed for healthcare senior executives. These brief, bi-annual issues focus on topics relevant to top-tier hospital leadership. For each topic, you can find related references, resources, and tools.

Hospital Executive Insights Past Issues

Exclusive Access

Take advantage of our 2021 professional partnership levels of support to receive exclusive early access to The Alliance Insight Series publications.

You’ll still have access to all our materials when they go online one month after publication.

*Bronze Circle is a one-time introductory level for first-time Professional Partner organizations. While this opportunity carries limited benefits, it is intended to provide introductory access to The Alliance’s diverse programs and learning solutions. Current Professional Partners are exempt from this option.
Man Holding Green Ribbon For Supporting People Living And Illness. Liver, Gallbladders Bile Duct, Kidney Cancer And Lymphoma Awareness Month Concept
This issue will focus on the UAGA’s position regarding First Person Authorization for donation (i.e. when a person legally registers to be an organ, eye and tissue donor).

Legal Aspects of a Registered Donor

Nearly every hour, another person dies waiting for an organ transplant. Despite significant technological improvements and numerous public service campaigns, the substantial shortage continues for organs, tissues and eyes for life-saving or lifeimproving transplants. This need led the way for legislation to provide national uniformity for organ, eye and tissue donation. This issue will focus on the UAGA’s position regarding First Person Authorization for donation (i.e. when a person legally registers to be an organ, eye and tissue donor).

1. The UAGA is the Legal Foundation for Organ and Tissue Donation

The Uniform Anatomical Gift Act (UAGA) is the law that governs deceased donation. The UAGA was first drafted in 1968 and revised in 1987 and 2006. The UAGA was used as a model legislation for state law, and every state passed the original version. Today, 47 states have enacted the 2006 version which increased the focus on personal autonomy in the donation process. To find your state’s UAGA, visit our Organ Donation Toolbox and select the Legal & Regulatory Section.

2. Gift Law Governs Anatomical Donations

The legal basis upon which human organs and tissues can be donated for transplantation is based on gift law principles, not informed consent. Informed consent is a legal principle that applies to healthcare treatment decisions. Gift law requires three elements: intent, transfer and acceptance. As such, the donation gift is a voluntary, legally binding, uncompensated transfer from one individual to another.

3. First Person Authorization Means a Donor’s Autonomous Decision is Final

Individuals have the right to make a legally-binding anatomical gift prior to gift. No permission from the donor’s family is warranted. The law firmly states that a donor’s autonomous decision to make an anatomical gift is not subject to change by others.

4. Even if Families Object, the Donor’s Decision Must be Honored

Although the UAGA definitively authorizes an individual to “gift” organs and tissues without family approval, fear of litigation and negative media have driven the practice of obtaining family consent. However, there have been no reported cases of a family successfully suing healthcare or donation professionals when an individual has made a valid donation designation.

5. Our Obligation is to Respect and Honor the Autonomy Rights of the Donor

The UAGA upholds the rights of the individual to make an anatomical gift. Therefore, a donor’s autonomous decision to donate must be honored. The OPO may conduct any blood or tissue test or minimally invasive exam reasonably necessary to evaluate the suitability of the gift, pre-consent, pre-declaration. The hospital shall not withdraw measures necessary to maintain the suitability of a gift until the OPO has had the chance to advise the hierarchy of the donation option. (UAGA C.26:6-89)

(add image)

Leading the Charge

Helpful Resources

Questions & Comments

Worth Sharing
CSuite Snapshot Fall 2017 FINAL

A Special Thanks to This Series’ Contributors

DD6A2041 JD Edited
About the Editor |
Corey Bryant

Corey Bryant brings more than 15 years of communications experience to The Alliance, having served in communications and public relations roles for Disney Parks and Resorts, Disney Cruise Line and TransLife (now OurLegacy), the OPO serving East Central Florida. He has also been an active board member of Donate Life Florida, having served as state team leader for Driver License Outreach. Corey is a proud alum of The University of Alabama and serves on the board of directors for Come Out With Pride Orlando as well as Five Horizons Health Services, a not-for-profit organization providing access to progressive HIV testing, prevention and LGBT+ focused healthcare throughout West Alabama and East Mississippi.

Glenn Matsuki
About the Editor |
Glenn Matsuki

Glenn is an accomplished donation and transplant professional and national speaker. He is a passionate donation and transplantation advocate, educator, project manager and consultant. He brings nearly 20 years of transplant and organ procurement organization experience. He has extensive hands-on experience working with multidisciplinary hospital care teams, with an emphasis on relationships, regulatory/accreditation compliance, strategic planning and core competencies. He is a 25-year heart transplant recipient who enjoys his free time gardening, traveling and contributing to his Organ and Tissue Donation Blog.

Advancing All.

The Alliance is not a membership organization and therefore relies on annual voluntary financial support from OPOs and transplant programs who find value in our programs and initiatives.

We invite you to join us as a 2021 professional partner